Chicago Fire 1871 with Train
Going vs Staying: The Ellen Gibbons Story

 An eternal question: When do you stick it out? When do you hit the road?

This audio story is about my great-grandmother Ellen Gibbons, who wanted the good life and didn't mind picking up and moving to get it. She arrived in Chicago from Ireland on the eve of the Great Fire of 1871. Did she stick around to help with reconstruction? Hell no...The story is true, based on oral history, conveyed through the generations and verified with immigration and census data. The only mystery is what exactly she was doing in St Louis for the 10 years before she got married and moved out to the farm. We can assume she worked as a domestic for one of the wealthy St Louis families -- a common occupation for young Irish women, who often came to America on their own and networked with sisters and aunts to become self-supporting.The background on this photo-montage is the aftermath of the 1871 fire in Chicago. The train is for getting out of town on.

Comments

Good stuff, nice music. I'll be adding this to the on-air library. I wonder how going vs. staying has changed over the years as we've become a more mobile society. How long do you have to stay in one place to be the "roots"?
Jesse -- Interesting article on just your questions in Sunday's New York Times: The American Wanderer, in All His Stripes: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/24/weekinreview/24powe.html?ex=1377316800&en=4781e12c4dc89bf3&ei=5124&partner=permalink&exprod=permalink ... our american perception of rootlessness vs being settled, as applied to our presidential candidates. Good for an interesting discussion. Cosmorochester
Great questions. When I look at immigrants and migrants in my family (incl my own migrations), there were years of picking up and going, then finally settling down to plant roots. Staying vs going applies to relationships too!